Injury Law October 26, 2026 · 9 min read

Harland v. West Hollywood: Why Filing a Government-Injury Lawsuit Too Soon Can Derail Your Claim

The California Supreme Court is reviewing whether suing a public entity too soon after filing a government claim is premature. Here is what injured Californians need to know.

When you are hurt because a city sidewalk collapsed, a county road was dangerously designed, or a public bus driver ran a red light, the path to compensation looks very different than a typical car crash case. California law forces you through a special pre-lawsuit process known as the government claims procedure, and the margin for error is unforgiving. One timing mistake can wipe out an otherwise strong case.

That is exactly what is now in front of the California Supreme Court. In Harland v. City of West Hollywood, the Court of Appeal threw out an injury lawsuit as premature because the plaintiff filed in court only two days after mailing her government claim, before the city had the full statutory window to respond. The Supreme Court has granted review, which means the appellate ruling is no longer ordinary binding precedent, but the underlying trap is very real. Below, we walk through what the dispute means for injured Californians, how the timeline actually works, and what you should be doing while the public entity sits on your claim.

The Government Claims Act in Plain Language

Under the Government Claims Act, codified in Government Code sections 810 and following, you generally cannot sue a California public entity for personal injury without first presenting a written claim to that entity. The claim has to be presented within six months of the injury for most personal injury cases, as set out in Government Code section 911.2. Miss that six-month window and your case is almost always over before it starts. We have written separately about that deadline trap, and it still catches people every month.

But the six-month filing deadline is only the first hurdle. Once you present the claim, the public entity has 45 days to act on it under Government Code section 912.4. During that window, the entity can accept the claim, reject it, offer a compromise, or do nothing. If the entity does nothing, the claim is deemed rejected by operation of law when the 45 days expire.

Only after that process plays out can you file a lawsuit in superior court. That is where Harland comes in.

What Happened in Harland v. City of West Hollywood

The plaintiff in Harland was injured on allegedly dangerous public property in West Hollywood. She mailed her government claim to the city and then, just two days later, filed her personal injury lawsuit in superior court. She had not waited for the city to act, and she had not waited for the 45-day response period to run out.

The Court of Appeal held the lawsuit was premature. In the court’s view, the suit was filed before the city had the chance Government Code section 912.4 gives it to evaluate and respond to the claim. The appellate panel treated that timing problem as a fatal defect in the lawsuit itself.

The California Supreme Court then granted review. That has two important consequences for injured Californians right now:

  1. The Court of Appeal opinion is not citable as ordinary binding precedent while review is pending.
  2. The Supreme Court will give a definitive answer on whether, and when, filing before the response period expires actually bars the case.

Until the Supreme Court speaks, trial courts across California are navigating this issue with mixed guidance. That uncertainty is itself a reason to be extremely conservative about timing.

The Timeline That Protects Your Case

Public entity cases live and die on calendars. Here is how we think about the sequence from our side of the desk, and how we recommend injured Californians think about it as well.

Day of injury. The six-month clock under Government Code section 911.2 starts running. Preserve everything you can from the scene. Photos of the hazard, the lighting, the surface, the signage, the weather. Public conditions can be repaired or altered within days, and once that happens, the evidence is gone.

Within six months. Present a written claim that complies with Government Code section 910. That means your name, address, the date and place of the incident, a description of the circumstances, the public employees involved if known, and the amount claimed or an indication that the amount exceeds the limited civil jurisdiction. Technical defects at this stage can cost you the case entirely.

The 45-day response period. This is the window at the heart of Harland. The entity may send a formal rejection, which starts a six-month statute of limitations to sue under Government Code section 945.6(a)(1). Or the entity may stay silent, in which case the claim is deemed rejected at the end of the 45 days, and you then have two years to sue under section 945.6(a)(2). Filing suit before the response period concludes is what the Harland Court of Appeal flagged as premature.

After rejection. File your superior court lawsuit within the applicable deadline. If you got a formal written rejection with proper notice, that is six months. If the claim was simply deemed rejected by silence, it is two years, but we do not recommend waiting. Memories fade, witnesses move, and public entity defendants are relentless about procedural challenges.

Why Premature Filing Is Such a Dangerous Mistake

Filing early feels like diligence. It is not. In the public entity context, early filing can look to a defense attorney like an opening to file a demurrer or motion for judgment on the pleadings. Their argument is simple: the plaintiff did not satisfy the prerequisites of the Government Claims Act because the entity never got the response window it is entitled to.

If the court agrees, the lawsuit gets dismissed. By the time that happens, the statute of limitations on refiling may have already expired, and the six-month claim window is long gone. In other words, the mistake is often not fixable.

That is the real risk Harland highlights, regardless of how the Supreme Court ultimately rules. Even if the Court decides that a premature filing can be cured, you do not want your case to be the test. Waiting the full 45 days, or waiting for a formal written rejection, costs you nothing and protects everything.

What to Do While the Public Entity Is Sitting on Your Claim

The 45-day response window is not downtime. It is some of the most important time in the entire case, and this is where John’s two decades as a chiropractor before he became a lawyer shape how we handle these matters.

Get consistent medical care and document it carefully. Public entity defendants are aggressive about arguing that injuries were pre-existing, exaggerated, or unrelated to the hazard. Gaps in treatment are their favorite argument. We encourage clients to follow through on every referral, keep every appointment, and make sure the medical records clearly connect the mechanism of injury to the diagnosis. When John reviews a chart, he is reading it the way a defense expert will read it later. Clean, consistent, well-documented care is one of the strongest answers to a causation attack.

Preserve the scene. Public property changes. A broken sidewalk gets poured over. A missing stop sign gets replaced. A dangerous crosswalk gets repainted. Photos, video, and measurements taken during the 45-day window can be the only objective evidence of what the condition actually looked like when you were hurt. We often send investigators out immediately to document the location.

Identify witnesses now. Neighbors, nearby business owners, delivery drivers who use the route daily. These people have information about how long the hazard existed, which goes directly to the notice requirement for dangerous condition claims under Government Code section 835.

Request public records. Prior complaints, maintenance logs, prior incident reports, and design documents are often obtainable through the Public Records Act. These documents frequently show that the entity knew about the hazard long before your injury.

Do not give a recorded statement to the entity’s risk management office or its third-party administrator. The same rules we apply to private insurance adjusters apply here. Anything you say will be used to narrow the claim.

How Harland Fits Into a Bigger Pattern

Harland is not an isolated case. California appellate courts have been active on public entity liability questions, including design immunity under Government Code section 830.6 and the limits of warning sign claims after the Tansavatdi remand. Public entities and their insurers are using every procedural lever available to defeat claims before they reach a jury.

The through line is that these cases reward preparation and punish improvisation. Private car accident cases have real deadlines, but the system generally gives you some room to recover from early missteps. Government claims cases do not. The procedural rules are the case, at least until you get past the pleading stage.

Talk to Us Before the Clock Runs

If you were injured by a dangerous condition on public property, by a government vehicle, or by the conduct of a public employee anywhere in California, the smartest thing you can do is get the timeline right from day one. That means filing a compliant claim within six months, respecting the 45-day response window, and using the waiting period to build the medical and factual record your case will need.

The Supreme Court will eventually tell us exactly how strict the premature-filing rule is after Harland. Until then, we are counseling clients to be patient on filing and aggressive on preparation. It is a combination that keeps your case alive and keeps the leverage on your side.

If you have questions about a potential claim against a California city, county, state agency, transit district, or school district, we are happy to talk through the timeline and your options. Our consultations are free, and you do not owe us anything unless we recover for you. Call Reardon Injury Law at (657) 522-7122 and we will walk you through what to do next.

Injured? We Can Help.

Free consultation. No fees unless we win your case.

Call (657) 522-7122
📞 Call Now - (657) 522-7122